Ticket #51 (new enhancement)

Opened 18 months ago

Last modified 18 months ago

fractional dimensions

Reported by: ahendriks Owned by:
Priority: minor Milestone:
Keywords: dimension,fractional Cc:

Description

How does the UCUM cope with fractional dimensions, like the much used Chezy coefficient (friction coefficient in hydraulic engineering), which has m½/s as 'unit'?

Change History

Changed 18 months ago by gschadow

The answer is: we don't.

I have seen this, but I don't know enough of it to make sense of this. Obviously one can imagine to put any unit term under any root, but what does this mean? What is the square-root of a meter? Seem rather imaginary to me.

The formula is:

v = C * sqrt(R * i)

where C is this Chezy coefficient, R is radius, dimension L and i is dimensionless (a slope). So here we have a square root of a length. But what does this mean? I think the right way to write this formula would be:

v = sqrt(C2 * R * i)

and now your coefficient C2 has the dimension L.T-2, which looks much more reasonable.

I always felt that this fractional dimensionality is arrived at by some nifty engineering trick, as factoring the coefficient before the square root, but really doesn't signify that dimensions can somehow be fractional. [Sounds a bit analogously esoteric as Cantor's continuum hypothesis.]

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.